Opening hours
Opening hours not available
We don’t have confirmed opening hours for Sutter's Mill yet. Call (845) 357-6556 to check before you go.
Typical hours for American restaurants in New York
Most American restaurants in New York open around 11:00 AM and close around 10:00 PM on weekdays; 87% are open on Sundays and 65% stay open until 10 PM or later.
Based on 493 similar places in our guide.
Location & directions
214 Route 59 #1Suffern, NY 10901
About Sutter's Mill
Sutter's Mill is an American restaurant located at 214 Route 59 #1 in Suffern, New York. It is one of 27 places to eat and drink we list in Suffern.
Available service options are dine-in.
Phone: (845) 357-6556.
Quick facts
- Category
- American Restaurant
- Address
- 214 Route 59 #1, Suffern, NY 10901
- Phone
- (845) 357-6556
- Listing updated
- · Suggest an edit
Popular times (typical for American restaurants)
American restaurants are usually busiest around 6 PM on Fridays; one of the quieter times is around 3 PM on weekdays.
Based on typical visit patterns and the usual opening hours of American restaurants in New York.
Typical prices for American restaurants in New York
Based on 131 menus with 8,257 priced items from American restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $13.00, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $18.90.
We don’t have Sutter's Mill’s own menu on file yet, so use these figures as a guide to what American restaurants in New York typically charge.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Caesar Salad | 23% | $14.00 |
| French Fries | 22% | $7.00 |
| Onion Rings | 18% | $6.99 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | 17% | $11.80 |
| Cheeseburger | 16% | $11.00 |
| Sweet Potato Fries | 16% | $8.00 |
| Chicken Wings | 15% | $16.99 |
| Hamburger | 15% | $10.00 |
Calculated from 131 menus in our guide. Prices vary by location and change over time.
Features & amenities
Service options
- Dine-in
The neighborhood
Within a 10-minute walk (half a mile) of Sutter's Mill there are 11 other places to eat and drink in our guide, and 16 within one mile. By type, the places within a mile include Burgers & Fast Food (3), Sandwiches & Delis (3), Cafes & Coffee (2), and Bakeries & Desserts (2).
Sutter's Mill is the only American restaurant within a mile (1 within three miles). The next closest is Mahway Bar & Grill, 2.1 mi away.
4 places within a mile stay open until 10 PM or later on at least one night a week.
Nearest places of other kinds
- PizzaMama Mia's< 0.1 mi
- Mexican & Tex-MexGuacamole Mexican Grill Suffern< 0.1 mi
- Cafes & CoffeeBagel Boys Cafe< 0.1 mi
- Japanese & SushiAJ's Sushi & Cajun Seafood Restaurant< 0.1 mi
- Sandwiches & DelisJersey Mike's Subs< 0.1 mi
What to expect at an American restaurant
American restaurants cover a lot of ground: the neighborhood diner with a counter and bottomless coffee, the family restaurant with a long laminated menu, the gastropub doing elevated comfort food, and the “New American” kitchen that builds a short seasonal menu around local farms. What ties them together is a menu built on familiar staples – burgers, sandwiches, salads, steaks, fried chicken and pasta – plus regional favorites that change as you cross the country.
What to order
- Cheeseburger – the benchmark dish; a good one tells you how seriously the kitchen takes its basics
- Chicken-fried steak or fried chicken – a comfort classic, especially in the South and Midwest
- Mac and cheese – often a house side that doubles as a main
- A regional specialty – look for anything named after the town or state on the menu
Good to know
- Portions are generous; sharing a starter or ordering a half portion is common and rarely frowned upon.
- Weekday lunch specials and early-bird dinners often cost noticeably less than the regular menu.
- Tipping 18–20% on table service is standard across the US.
Reviews
Write a reviewNo visitor reviews yet. Been to Sutter's Mill? Share your experience to help other diners.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Sutter's Mill located?
Sutter's Mill is located at 214 Route 59 #1, Suffern, NY 10901.
What is the phone number of Sutter's Mill?
You can call Sutter's Mill at (845) 357-6556.
Does Sutter's Mill offer delivery or takeout?
Delivery is not listed for Sutter's Mill. Listed service options: dine-in.
What else is near Sutter's Mill?
There are 16 other places to eat and drink within a mile of Sutter's Mill. Nearby options include Mama Mia's (< 0.1 mi), Guacamole Mexican Grill Suffern (< 0.1 mi), and Bagel Boys Cafe (< 0.1 mi).
Are there other American restaurants near Sutter's Mill?
None within a mile. The closest is Mahway Bar & Grill, 2.1 mi away.
How much do American restaurants in New York cost?
Based on 131 menus with 8,257 priced items from American restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $13.00, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $18.90.
Nearby places
All in Suffern
Listing data © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Details may have changed – please verify with the business.